What Makes a Great Validator Response?

Ever wonder what kind of feedback makes a validator great?

At ValidateLens, we review responses to ensure quality — and here's what we consider top-tier.

1. Specificity

Great validators don’t just say “this won’t work.” They explain why.

"I’m not convinced people would download another app just to track free trials — unless it does something else too."

2. Thoughtfulness

Validators who engage deeply with the idea — considering the real-world use case, alternatives, and risks — provide the most value.

3. Constructive Tone

Even if the idea isn’t ready, helpful feedback keeps the founder motivated. Good validators critique the idea, not the person.

4. Clarity

Validators who write clearly and concisely — without jargon or fluff — help you move faster.

5. Actionability

The best responses don’t just analyze — they suggest a next step.

“You might consider narrowing this down to freelancers who manage multiple tools.”

Bonus: When Validators Ask You Questions

That’s gold. It means they’re engaging deeply and want to help sharpen the idea.

👉 Want feedback like this? Submit your idea today